Gaining Valuable Experience Through Pro Bono
The Clark County Bar Association’s December issue of Communiqué is dedicated to pro bono and the promotion of access to justice in Nevada. The magazine features an article from John Fortin titled “Gaining Valuable Experience Through Pro Bono: An Example from Civil Forfeiture.” John shares insights from his current pro bono work and describes how pro bono representation creates opportunities for young lawyers to gain invaluable experience early in their careers. John’s article is provided below and on pages 20 and 21 in the magazine here.
John has received both 300 Hours Club and Pro Bono Volunteer of the Month recognition from the Legal Aid Center of Southern Nevada. John’s pro bono work is also featured in the following publications:
“The government took their home. Now, a family’s lawsuit may change Nevada’s forfeiture system,” The Nevada Independent, Sept. 10, 2023
“Attorneys Work To Take The ‘Civil’ Out Of Civil Forfeiture,” Law360 Access to Justice, March 11, 2023
“Nevada lawyer seeks to upend state’s forfeiture laws,” Reuters Daily Docket, Jan. 20, 2023
Gaining Valuable Experience Through Pro Bono:
An Example from Civil Forfeiture
by John Fortin
By seeking out and providing pro bono representation, the legal profession is indisputably enriched and young lawyers in particular gain invaluable experience early in their careers. My pro bono practice has thus far been focused on civil rights. I have predominantly represented the rights of my clients when they have faced property forfeitures. Through pro bono work, I have been fortunate to present two oral arguments before the Supreme Court of Nevada, signed an amicus brief which led to a groundbreaking civil rights decision in Nevada, and gained and honed litigation strategy and appellate practice skills that I apply every day to my private practice.
Generally, civil forfeitures of property are authorized by statute and the law relies upon a legal fiction that the property committed the crime. In Nevada, property forfeitures can only occur when a criminal defendant is found guilty at trial or through a plea bargain. Following the criminal proceeding, the property—a home, a car, or the cash found on or near a defendant—may then be forfeited to the government. To be sure, removing the ill-gotten gains of criminal networks is sound public policy. However, as has been well documented, most property forfeitures fall on those least able to defend themselves against the forfeiture as opposed to the well-funded and well-represented El Chapos whom the forfeiture laws are designed to deter.
These impacted individuals (who may be relatives, spouses, or intimate partners and innocent of the underlying criminal conduct) can barely afford to meet their daily needs—let alone afford counsel. The loss of a home, a car, or even the little cash they might have in their pockets for a few days normally spells disaster. Their challenge involves more than money; it involves time. Property forfeiture proceedings can take years and preventing access to the seized property can truly upend the lives of those most vulnerable and their families.
While there are cases pending before both the Nevada and United States Supreme Courts that could address some of these issues, more robust fixes likely would involve the state legislature and/or the bar. On the legislative front, our representatives could enact greater innocent property owner protections. Until those underlying reforms happen, the bar is best positioned to consider investing more pro bono resources to support those in need who face property forfeitures. Unfortunately, property forfeiture is an area of law that is often under the radar, but it is an area of law where young lawyers will find an extraordinary opportunity to make a difference at the intersection of law, public policy, and humanity.
My experience in defending claimants and innocent property owners has provided meaningful assistance to those in need, enriched my practice, and truly made me understand the humbling power a license to practice law can provide to our community.
About McDonald Carano
In 2024, McDonald Carano celebrates 75 years of serving Nevada’s legal, business, government, and civic communities. More than 60 lawyers and government relations professionals serve state, national, and international clients from our offices in Reno, Las Vegas, and Carson City. McDonald Carano provides legal services and government affairs and advocacy counsel to startups, corporations, trade associations, nonprofits, public entities, high-net-worth individuals, investors, and public-private partnerships throughout Nevada. We are proud to be your Nevada law firm since 1949.
You have chosen to send an email to McDonald Carano. The sending or receipt of this email and the information in it does not in itself create an attorney-client relationship. If you are not already a client, you should not provide us with information that you wish to have treated as privileged or confidential without first speaking to one of our lawyers. If you provide information before we confirm that you are a client and that we are willing and able to represent you, we may not be required to treat that information as privileged, confidential, or protected information, and we may be able to represent a party adverse to you.
I have read this and want to send an email.